Saturday, February 13, 2016

Since, Everything Can't Be Yours! - Story by Manvi Singh in Crush 2

Review

Akshara is always blushed whenever she looks upon a folded paper secretly kept in her cupboard since forty years. Was it a love letter or something else? To find, read this story in Crush 2 by Manvi Singh, I assume the youngest among all the contributory authors to this anthology.

Merits: Manvi Singh has come out with a story which will fill you with nostalgia as your reading progresses. This will remind you the lighter moments of your own life you experience specially at your teenage stage of life.

Lines I liked: "That's how effective his smile was to her, innocent yet tickling every conscious part of her."

Demerits: We can not expect a perfect story by a writer as young as sixteen years old. So despite all the flaws in narration, she deserves kudos. However,a lot of improvement is required in some areas like grammar and sentence formation in general. She must take the help of a senior or an editor before submitting her story in future.
The second drawback of the story is-- it is placed just after A Little Like Love, having the same theme where a mother tells her story to her daughter, ensuing a disinterest in the reader. The editors should've placed it somewhere else in the book and for this Manvi is not responsible.
Another flaw is that this story has been repeated many a times and has become redundant since the release of Hum Apke Hain Kaun and is too common to create an interest in the minds of the readers. Readers want something new!


Ratings: 2/5

It's really difficult for a young girl of sixteen to imagine a story of a woman of fifty plus. I appreciate her efforts and wish all the best for her in future.

Rajeev Pundir

Friday, February 12, 2016

That Rikshaw: Story by Monojit Dutta in Crush 2

REVIEW

In life we all have fond memories of sweet, lemon, sour and spicy experiences which continue to thrill us time and again throughout whole of our existence. Monojit Dutta has brought out such a story which will remind you your own fun loving memories and warm your heart taking back to your school days. Read the story to fulfill yourself with that strange sensation you would have felt sometime in your life.

Merits: The way Monojit has narrated the story in a good flow is excellent. It, I bet, will certainly take your present to your past and will oblige you to smile on remembering your own lighter moments you would have come across in your life some or the other time.

Lines I liked the most: "I don't eat something that is meant for someone else." " How long are you going to pretend of being a nice person?"

Demerits: The story starts with a chance meeting of a boy and a girl for hiring a rickshaw and sharing their tiffins. However the story runs in a linear fashion, it remains confined to the rickshaw and sharing the food only. Therefore, at times the reader feels monotonous. Repetition of any activity makes it redundant and to remove this flaw, the writer would have imagined and included a variety of different interesting lighter moments happening between the boy and the girl.

Ratings: 4/5
Overall, a good job by Monojit and I look forward more interesting stories from his pen. All the best!

Rajeev Pundir

Thursday, February 11, 2016

A Little Like Love - Story by Samridhi Garg in Crush 2

REVIEW

The story commences with the observation of a mother Sarika when she spots her daughter Ana in a tad subdued mood. When she tries to know the reason of her lowly comportment, Ana denies anything specific. But a mother is a mother and gets instantly what the matter was. To know further--read a wonderful story written by Samridhi Garg in Crush 2 published by Author's Ink Publication.

Merits:
The conversation between a mother and her daughter has been portrayed beautifully. Each sentence is meticulously crafted and  each paragraph is supplemented by either a simile, a figure of speech or an adjective at appropriate places. Wonderful! The frank, truthful and friendly discussion between the two is an eye opener for conservative parents.

The sentence worth mentioning: "No. I never missed him after I met your dad and I never regretted. Your dad is such a gem. He helped me to move on and taught me how to fall in love again."

Demerits: The above sentence is self explanatory. On one side it shows the truthfulness of a mother's confession before her daughter about her feelings for her first love or crush, her selfishness is also expressed in a straight non-emotional manner for the person she liked once on the other.This could've been presented in another way showing some sympathetic attitude towards her teenage-crush.

Ratings 4.5/5

Wish her all the best for her forthcoming writings which I would like to read definitely.
Well done!

Rajeev Pundir

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

The Love Letter- story by Ashquanda Iqbal in Crush 2

Review

This is a story of two students Rhea and Rudraksh studying as junior and senior in the same school.
Slowly they develop a liking for each other which changes into crush and later on into love. Rudraksh writes a love letter to her to express his feelings for her. Read the story to know what happens when she reads his love letter.

Merits:

It was  almost a treat to read this story written by a girl Ashquanda Iqbal we hardly find around us as young as studying in class XII. The characters have been developed according to their nature and the story flows with lucidity maintaining the curiosity for the reader.

The line I liked: "And then, when our eyes met, it was the most glorious micro second of my life."


Demerits:
To tell about demerits of a write-up doesn't mean to discourage the writer but improve. Ashquanda is too young to be perfect and has a tremendous capacity to become an accomplished writer. Although she has tried her best, she has to improve a lot. First, the love letter in itself is too long and I think it could have been shortened using more effective emotions and powerful sentences for the same message a lover wants to convey to his beloved. Anything which is expressed in detail more than it's required shows lack of confidence in the lover.
In the very first paragraph, there is a flaw. This flaw pertains to the imagination of the writer's tender age and I hope her to improve with her maturity. The flaw is: twinkling of stars perfectly in a cloudy or sparsely cloudy sky after two hours of heavy rains. These two situations are antagonistic and do not occur altogether. Either you see one or the other.
Then there's is inappropriate use of certain words like- eyes dropped, confronting you and smirked. I suggest her to consult the dictionary before using the words to convey the correct meaning of that particular emotion and action.

Ratings: 2.5/5
I wish all the best for Ashquanda for her literary endeavor as she has a big potential as a writer.

Rajeev Pundir

Tuesday, February 9, 2016

The Discarded Gift: Story by Divya PS Rawat in Crush 2


Dear Divya,


Read your story...I mean written by you in Crush 2 and I liked it to the core of my heart. It's very emotional and touching for the readers filling them with the process of changing their crush into love, silently. A wonderful read indeed.

The line I liked- "Holding the storm of tears in my eyes, I also accepted her last handshake with my trembling hand."

Merits:

Both the characters has been developed precisely enveloping them into feelings and emotions they have for each other.



Demerits: Although I liked the story, new generation may find it a bit awkward as they don't have that much patience as far as expression of their love is concerned. 

But old is gold. Amazing!
Keep it up! Wish you all the best for your forthcoming writings.

Ratings: 4.5/5

Rajeev Pundir



Wednesday, December 23, 2015

Review of Take 2 by Ruchi Singh



After marrying Sameer, her childhood love, Priya gets a job in Delhi. Subsequently, they shift to Delhi from their home town Kanpur. Sameer is highly ambitious and wants to make a career in modelling. As a struggler he sustains on the income earned by Priya. Their relationship sours when Sameer ditches and dumps her for a well-established top model Jessica and starts to live with her. Then, she happens to meet Abhimanyu, a cousin of her friend Komal. He instantly falls for her and the story begins.
Being attracted towards a married woman, Abhimanyu is warned and becomes a bit apprehensive about the future of this relationship. On the other hand, keeping in view of her marital status, though on rocks, Priya too is not very enthusiastic about her future with Abhi, at least till the case of her divorce is settled. This is a story of love, hate, vengeance, jealousy, compromises and compulsions. Whether Priya and Abhi manage to turn the tide in their favor, read Take 2 by Ruchi Singh, published by Author’s Ink Publications, Rohtak.
Pros:
The strongest point of this novel is its narration. Though the story is simple having not much twists and turns and runs in linear fashion, its language has made it extremely interesting. The command of the authoress over the language impresses and even sometimes hypnotizes the reader for a spellbound reading. The novel is edited perfectly and typed with dexterity leaving no space for spelling or grammar mistakes. Congratulations!
Cons:
The story is so simple that at times it generates a tad disinterest in the mind of a reader. I wouldn’t say that it drags, but certainly it slows down as nothing much happens between the protagonists; courtesy to their war of nerves. The subplot, when Abhimanyu is falsely trapped by his colleague Vikram on the pretext of causing a serious roadside accident to him, is loosely knit, technically erroneous and fails to convince the reader beyond reasonable comprehension. Accidents are police cases and need immediate medical examination of the injured person in a government hospital and neither the police nor the doctors are so naïve not to judge the cocks-and-bull story of a person who pretends as seriously injured that he stays in comma for two days, not even when bribed.
Final Take:
Ruchi Singh has done a commendable job by presenting a simple story in a very crispy and lucid language and I look forward for more books from her pen. Best of luck!



An excerpt from Take 2 :
“A wave of regret and sorrow moved on his face. He caught hold of her arms and jerked her against him. She gasped. Plastering her against him, he kissed her, as if there’s no tomorrow. Then he pushed her free, as if she was a piece of smoldering coal and stormed out of the house, slamming the door shut.” Page 140.
New words I learned:       Beanpole, Eon, Balk, Chignon, Muss, Brocade, Sweet-nothings and Chagrin
Rating: 3.5/5

By Rajeev Pundir



Monday, October 26, 2015

RAPE: AN AVOIDABLE MISHAP



Firstly a bitter story…
Long back, when I was a consultant in Moolchand Medicity, two boys; one in twenties and the other in teens, entered my OPD. It was their third or fourth visit for getting some treatment for their non-specific abdominal complaints. In routine, I asked them how they were feeling. They said—fine. And they stopped like thinking to say something but hesitating. Getting them confused, as they had become a bit friendly to me during this period of their visits, I asked them to say whatever they want to without hesitation, but fast as other patients were waiting for their turn.
“Sir, do you have something to increase the sexual power?” the younger one mumbled shyly.
In the first place, I was surprised on the query which was embarrassing enough not only for them but for me too to reply—to my too young patients seeking treatment for sexual disorder. To get a clear idea, as I was not expecting them to have medicine to increase their libido at this age, I asked, “Yes, we have. For whom?”
This time the elder one stuttered, “For ourselves—sir.”
“Yourself?” I exclaimed.
“Yes sir,” they nodded.
“Are you, I mean, both of you married?” I asked them in amazement. I also knew that they were real brothers.
“No,” they nodded in negation.
“Then, must be having girlfriends?” I quipped and laughed towards them—supposing them a bit misguided and confused by their peers boasting their unstoppable, enormous sexual prowess— a normal phenomenon among friends making them subdued with inferiority complex.
“No sir,” they replied having an stilted smile showing their embarrassment.
Perhaps they were expecting me to write a prescription for them, in routine, without going into deep details.
“Then, how do you know that you’re sexually weak? In fact, where do you test if you don’t have girlfriends?” I tried to know the reason simply as I did never expect a person at this age coming for sexual weakness.
And the answer they offered shocked and shook me to the core.
Aunties,” one of them replied.
Their demeanor was telling that they were serious and not joking in any manner. However, I couldn’t trust on my ears hearing that word—aunties!
For a while I was dumbstruck. I looked at them in utter disbelief and astonishment and tried to get an elaborated account what did they mean.
“Aunties? What do you mean?” I wondered and frowned at them.
“Sir, our immediate neighbors and a few of our mom’s friends,” the elder one told. Till that time their shyness had vanished and they had become quite frank—brazen to say precisely.
“How?” flabbergasted, I asked again.
“Aunties, who remain lonely when their husbands are away on official tours for weeks and their children are in school, they call us, serve us the best of wines and show us the porn movies on TV. This is great fun. But they’re too demanding. That’s why we’ve come to you,” the younger one described their hunky-dory with their femme fatale aunties.
Being an astute observer by nature, I tried to know more and out of curiosity asked them, “Do your mom not know all or something about it?”
“No sir! Not the least. When they come to our home to have a chat with mom, we even don’t see eye-to-eye,” and they tittered.
Stunned, I closed my eyes. Perhaps that was my first encounter with the harsh and ugly reality of our society—where our neighbors, relatives, family friends, known-to-uncles and aunties and cousins are exploiting our kids and playing extremely dirty and shameful games behind the veils—behind the veils of our good-relations with them.
How dangerous they can be, I thought.

The above incident, which is not one off, coincides with the statistics of rape and sodomy cases in our society putting the onus on only ones—the known ones in more than 80% cases. (Please refer the latest news items’ headlines attached as a photograph.) Even a few celebrities (name withheld), both male and female, have accepted that they were molested, raped and sodomized by their close-relatives and family-friends during their childhood.



Now the moot question is—can we prevent it?
YES, to some extent—provided we take a few cautious measures.
1.      Be possessive about your wards till they cross their education at least at school level.
2.      Never trust anyone, whosoever maybe; a servant, a maid, a family friend, a relative, a tenant, a landlord, a neighbor and other fringe elements visiting your house time-to-time like presswala, sabziwala, plumber, electrician etc. etc.
3.      Learn to distrust anyone coming in contact your kids; a teacher, a tutor, their playmates and school friends including all the above as mentioned at no.2
4.      Keep a close watch and strict vigil on the behavior of the above mentioned people. Beware! You maybe dodged by their extremely cordial, sweet and friendly attitude towards all your family members.
5.      Don’t allow your kids to play with others in separate rooms or in lonely parks. NEVER.
6.      Gone are the days when we would visit our relatives on maternal and paternal sides during winter and summer vacations. Yet, if you’re obliged to visit for some unavoidable reasons, don’t allow your little ones to sleep with any of your relatives or their kids—howsoever nice they maybe.
7.      It’s easy to proclaim that the girls should have all kinds of liberties and be allowed to roam anytime anywhere. Yes, I’m also the big proponent of all kinds of freedom to the girls—but not at the cost of their security and dignity.
8.      Dear guys and gals, you’ve to save yourselves—by not strolling at odd hours, by not attending late-night parties, clubs, discos and pubs, by not mingling not only with strangers but with known ones at odd hours and at lonely places. If you do it, it’s your risk and no government may save you if you fall prey to some predator.
9.      If we think deep into our hearts—is all this possible? Dear friends, where boys are not safe in our society, can we expect a foolproof security and guarantee of the safety of our girls? And who’ll provide? The answer is obvious—NO.
10.  Never leave your innocent kids in the custody of a neighbor, a relative or whosoever maybe for whatsoever reason.
11.  Remember—even Sita was not spared and got kidnapped on being left alone by godly Ram and mighty Laxman. We’re nothing but petty human beings.
Dear friends, in any given society, crimes cannot be stopped absolutely. However, we can reduce them—by preventing them. And the above measures may seem to be impractical to invoke but I’m sure that our cautious attitude towards little things in our routine life may save our kids from the menace of rape, molestation and sodomy.
We cannot teach or preach morality and idealism or pray and beg the people not to rape and molest our children. Nobody is ready to listen. These are the hard hitting facts of our life—you may disagree but cannot deny them.
CHANCES TO BE HARMED BY UNKNOWN ARE SELDOM WHEREAS THE KNOWN MAY ATTACK LIKE A GORILLA ANYTIME—KEEPING AN EVIL EYE ON OUR KIDS 24X7, STEALTHILY.  
SO BEWARE OF THE KNOWN FIRST!
AS—PREVENTION IS ALWAYS BETTER THAN CURE.
Thanks for kind reading!!

                                                                                                           
 Rajeev Pundir, MD (Ayu.)
 An Ayurvedic specialist,    Novelist  and  a Columnist.